the discourse of this page:
what is a national identity, or a regional one, or the "feeling to belong to" a city, a clan, or some other group?
what makes people proud to be this or that? what makes people fight for one thing or the other? surely most people have more choices today than they had in WWI or do they not?
the music of one's hymn or national anthem, or maybe a folk song, or a lullaby that Mother or Grandfather used to sing can surely make one's heart beat faster, or it might give comfort in a difficult situation. what do you think?
also: what is the effect of such music at mass meetings?- may the venue be entirely recreational, political or a sporty occasion ( especially in anticipation of the coming Olympic Games)!
in different scenarios national anthems certainly have a different effect; some of the anthems are, no doubt, musical masterpieces and deserve to be listened to purely on this merit. the French Marseillaise, in my opinion, definitely belongs to this group, but also the Russian and German anthems and many others. the melody, texture and rhythm of many tunes give a description and idea of the country, the language and the temperament of the people, (comment?)
the German anthem surely sounds and feels very different in the Haydn string quartet version from the militaristic styled one of the Nazis.
Mireille Matthieu sings the French anthem with conviction, but not aggression.
the Czech anthem sounds very homely and the Finnish is surprisingly lively.
there is much to add and to edit, I just want to make a start.
Please, share your views! Thanks, mathymarge
